|
Piangete
Cantatas & Motets by Giacomo Carissimi
Concerto Delle Donne
Gill Ross
Donna Deam
Elin Manahan Thomas
Alastair Ross
David Miller
Early Music, November 2004
...A similar selection, also with three high
voices, is presented by the British group Concerto delle Donne. In
Piangete: Cantatas & Motets by Giancomo Carissimi there are also no
changes in the continuo line; however, the chitarrone would seem a more
authentic choice for such accompaniments, rather than a bowed string
instrument, whose adoption as the sine qua non of continuo scoring did not
occur until later in the century. In both these recordings the performance
is of a high level, though in the British example Carissimi's music finds
some context in expansive preludes by Kapsberger and keyboard works by
Frescobaldi and Rossi. This is a valuable way of underlining that
Carissimi was not working in isolation as - arguably - the greatest figure
of the period, but collaboratively participating in the extensive round of
feasts which comprised the Roman liturgical year.
|
|